A lone middle-aged man stands still and in focus at the centre of an empty railway platform at dusk while a departing train and blurred figures streak past him, cold twilight light with a last band of amber on the horizon.

The Other Side of Moving On

What the years since taught me about the coaching world’s favourite cure

When my marriage ended, I was handed the cure before I had finished understanding the injury. The word for it, in the world that had by then reorganised my wife, was mindset. Suffering, in that world, is not something that happens to you. It is a posture you have adopted, a story you have chosen and could just as easily choose differently. Change the story and the suffering lifts. Change your mindset and, voila, you move on.

I wrote in the companion to this piece about what her breakthrough looked like from the outside, from the position of the person it happened to rather than the person it happened for. This is the part that comes after. Not the leaving, but the long instruction that follows a leaving like this one, an instruction no single person has to deliver because a whole culture delivers it for them, and in time your own reflex delivers it too: get over it, why are you still living this, when will you just move on. And the reason I want to write it down is that I have now spent years unable to obey that instruction, and I have finally stopped regarding that as a failing of mine.

I know the promise intimately, because I tried to keep it. In the months after everything came apart I did the work the world prescribes, all of it. I read the books on why I was shy, as though my being an introvert were the fault line the marriage had fallen through. I signed up to the online mental health course and worked the modules. I paid for a coaching program on relationships and did every unit of it, until it dissolved into spiritual affirmation with nothing underneath. I put myself on a waiting list for a psychologist and, when I finally got one, went fortnightly for years. I was not a man refusing to change his mindset. I was a man doing almost nothing else. When my wife produced a new psychologist and passed her along to me, I even allowed the person who had left me to set the terms of my recovery from being left. I wanted those sessions to help me understand what had happened. She wanted them to help me move on. That difference looks small written down. It is the whole subject of this piece.

It would be dishonest to pretend the mindset promise is simply empty. There is a version of it that is trivially true. How we frame an event does shape how we carry it, and there are minor hurts, ordinary setbacks, everyday frustrations, that really do loosen their grip the moment you look at them a different way. If the claim stopped there it would be unremarkable and mostly correct. But the coaching world does not stop there, and it cannot afford to, because its market is not minor hurts. It sells transformation, and transformation needs a totalising claim: not that mindset helps with some things, but that mindset is the thing, that all suffering is at bottom a perceptual error, and that anyone still in pain is simply someone who has not yet done the work. That is the claim I was handed. And that is the claim the years since have quietly taken apart.

Because I did the work, and it did not lift. So one of two things had to be true. Either I was uniquely incapable, a man who could not manage the simple mental adjustment that the testimonials make sound like flipping a switch, or the model was wrong about what had happened to me. For a long time, primed by the same world that had taken my wife, I believed the first. It took years, and a great deal of evidence, to accept the second.

The evidence is the part that has come since. I went back through everything that survived those years, the messages, the cards, the notes, the ordinary record of an ordinary family. I was not looking to relitigate the marriage. I was looking, honestly, for the fracture. I had been told, never in so many words but unmistakably, that something must have been broken for this to happen, and that a clear-eyed person would find it and accept it and move on. So I looked for it. And it is not there. What I did find was a deep belief in manifesting. But even this future, included me in it. What the record shows, year after year, is a marriage that was not perfect and was not fractured either, that carried the normal strain of two people and a mortgage and children and held anyway, right up until the final stretch. The excuses given were fundamentally debunked by facts found. The discontent that was later offered as the reason for leaving does not appear anywhere in the contemporaneous account of the life. It arrives late, and it arrives from outside, in the company of a new workplace, a new language, and a new set of voices who reframed an intact family as an obstacle to becoming.

That is what I have learned since, and it matters here for one specific reason. The coaching frame told me the problem was my perception. That if I still hurt, I was still misperceiving. The record says the opposite. It says the event was real, and large, and did not warrant what I was told to feel about it, which was nothing, and quickly. My grief was not a distortion of a small event. It was an accurate response to a large one. And an accurate response to a real loss is not a mindset to be corrected. It is grief doing exactly what grief is for.

Which turns the whole prescription inside out. In the coaching world, a person who cannot move on is walking proof that the method works and they are failing it, the client who held themselves back, the anchor that had to be released. But run it the other way. A model that claims all suffering is mindset makes a testable promise: change the mind and the suffering resolves. I am a test of that promise. I changed everything I was told to change, and the suffering did not resolve, because it was never a mindset. It was a wound, a wound that has visible scars that are real and forever. My inability to move on is not my failure of the method. It is the method’s failure, observed over years in a single, willing, exhaustively compliant subject. The thing they cannot say in a testimonial is that sometimes the mindset does not shift because the mindset was never the problem, and no amount of reframing will close a wound that a real event actually made.

This is why “just move on” is not neutral advice, and never was. It is the ideology protecting itself. A grief that will not resolve on schedule is an embarrassment to a worldview built on the promise that all grief is optional, and so the grief must be relocated back into the griever as a defect, a stuckness, a refusal. The instruction to move on does not serve the person receiving it. It serves the story, the clean before-and-after that the transformation needs in order to keep being sold. The person told to get over it is being asked, one more time, to make the cost of someone else’s becoming disappear from the timeline, so that the becoming can go on looking like a triumph with no other side to it. People who consider themselves human behaviour experts who cannot see this, maybe are not human behaviour experts.

And here is the part that returns me to where the first piece started. The one being told to move on is the same one who was never consulted in the first place. Not consulted about the change, not consulted about its speed, not consulted about the price, and now expected to grieve it, if at all, on a clock set by other people. The instruction does not even come from her. She has been gone a long time, and I keep it that way; I do not want her voice in my life and it is not in it. It comes from everywhere else instead. It is in the ethos that has leaked out of the coaching room into ordinary talk, so that someone who knows none of the detail can still tell me it is up to me how I choose to deal with things. It is in my own head, in a measuring stick I absorbed from the same world long before it took my wife. And it is loudest where no one says anything at all, in the moments that need no words to land: walking past a grown son who knows his father hates his mother for what she did, and conversation is like passing an old friend, short and sweet then moves on, and the quiet afterward doing what no lecture could. A son who saw the damage, who also sees the ongoing damage, who has a choice between the damaged one or the big new manifested life of his mother and her second partner after the affair one walked away. A mother who was not honest with him though. That is the same worldview at both ends. The one that gave her permission to walk away and call it integrity is the one that recasts my being unable to follow as a mindset I have simply chosen to keep.

I have not moved on, and I am done apologising for it. Not because I am bitter, and not because I am stuck in the sense they mean, but because there was something real to grieve and grief that matches its cause is not a malfunction. And it was not one clean blow, the kind you brace for once and then count the days from. Ask me when it ended and I have two answers: about five years since the ground first moved, and only four since she was finally, fully gone, with a whole year of not-knowing stretched between them. That gap is the point. The thing was not done to me on a day. It was administered over more than a year and in many forms, a telling, a walking-back, a lie surfacing, an ending and then another ending, so there is no single wound to get over because there was never a single wound. There is no correct length for grieving that, and no clean anniversary I can be accused of failing to clear. The people who set the deadline are, without exception, the people who never had to feel it.

The coaching world owes the ones it tells to just change their mindset a reckoning with the ones who could not. Not because we are weak. Because we could not for a reason, and the reason is the thing their whole promise depends on never being true.

This is the side of moving on you never see in the testimonial. This is what the coaching world will not tell you.

And someone needs to.

Similar Posts