An empty institutional corridor with stacked classroom chairs on one side and a warmly lit closed boardroom door on the other, representing the choice to cut teaching staff while retaining leadership development programs.

The L&D That Outlasted the Layoffs

Four Corners is currently investigating something that anyone who has worked inside a corporatised institution will recognise immediately. The program, Campus Chaos, asks a question that sounds straightforward but cuts deep: have universities drifted from their core public purpose, and who are they really serving?

It is a good question. It is also, for some of us, a familiar one. Because six years ago, during the first wave of Covid pressure, at least one university-adjacent institution was already answering it, quietly, with its spending decisions.


When the cuts came, the program stayed

In early 2020, as the economic consequences of Covid began to register across Australian higher education, front-line teaching staff at one institution found themselves out of work. These were the people in the room with students. The people delivering the actual educational product. The engine, if you like, of what a teaching institution is supposed to do.

At the same time, an L&D program, expensive by any reasonable reckoning, continued. Individual coaching for staff engaged in the program continued. The vendor relationship continued.

Nobody stopped it.

That is the detail worth sitting with. Not that cuts were made, because cuts were inevitable. But that when forced to choose under genuine financial constraint, the institution protected the coaching infrastructure and shed the teachers.

Whatever the internal justification, that is what the spending record reveals. A priority, expressed not in a statement of values but in a budget decision.


The immunity of the coached

There is a pattern here that extends well beyond one institution in one crisis year, and it is worth naming plainly.

L&D programs, particularly those built around coaching, leadership development, and culture transformation, have a peculiar immunity to cuts that front-line staff do not have.

Part of this is structural. The people who commissioned the program are usually the people deciding what gets cut. The program represents their judgment, their vision, their investment in a particular idea of what the organisation should become. To cut it is to admit it was discretionary. That admission is difficult for people who have staked professional credibility on the idea that this kind of work is essential. Staff development is of course important. Right?

Part of this is ideological. Coaching culture, and the leadership development industry that surrounds it, is extraordinarily good at making itself feel necessary. The language it uses, transformation, alignment, culture, capability, is not the language of line items. It is the language of organisational identity. And identity is much harder to cut than a casual teaching contract.

So the teachers go. The program stays. And somewhere in a vendor’s quarterly report, the engagement numbers look fine.


The question Four Corners is asking

Four Corners reporter Steve Cannane frames the investigation around what happens when financial pressures are used to justify sweeping restructures, while staff and students are left to bear the consequences. He asks whether universities have drifted from their core public purpose.

These are the right questions. But they are questions that the coaching and L&D industry has been answering for years, in institutions far beyond universities, and largely without scrutiny.

The answer the industry keeps giving, through its spending patterns if not its stated rationale, is this: the program is the purpose. The people delivering the actual work are the variable cost.

That logic did not begin with Covid. It did not begin in higher education. It lives in every organisation that has decided that cultural transformation, delivered by an external vendor, is more essential than the people doing the core work.


Who is the institution really serving?

It is worth asking that question directly, not just of universities, but of any institution that reaches for coaching and leadership development programs as a response to organisational complexity.

When a teaching organisation cuts teachers and retains coaches, it has revealed something about what it believes it is for. Not in its mission statement. Not in its values document. In the decision it made when it had to choose.

Front-line staff, whether teachers in a university, clinicians in a health service, or workers in any organisation asked to absorb cultural change from above, are the engine of institutional purpose. They are also, almost invariably, the first to go.

The L&D program, by contrast, sits closer to the people making cuts. It flatters the decision-makers. It tells them they are transforming something, leading something, building something that matters.

Four Corners is right to ask who universities are really serving. The answer, in at least some cases, begins with whoever sold them the program.

Similar Posts