How Coaching Exploits Perfectionism
Leon Garber LMHC’s article “Why People Pleasers Tend to Take Everything Personally” captures something I have witnessed up close: the psychological torment of people-pleasing perfectionism. Garber describes how socially prescribed perfectionists, those who internalise others’ expectations, live in constant conflict between their own needs and what they think others demand of them.
It is an exhausting way to live. When that mindset collides with the coaching industry and its pseudoscientific narratives of “manifesting”, “alignment”, and “growth”, the damage can be profound. I saw that combination play out in someone I loved, and it ultimately destroyed not just her peace of mind but our relationship and family.
1. Black and White Thinking: The Trap of Perfection
Garber writes:
“While some part of them rejects the external pressure to overextend themselves, black-and-white thinking may form the foundation of their belief that being a good anything means doing it right, to the extreme, and perfectly.”
She embodied this. As an English literature student, she always wanted to write a book but never could, because nothing she wrote was ever perfect enough. Drafts were started and abandoned. Ideas, always in motion, never became finished work. Ironically, when she began writing blogs for her coaching business, the quality was excellent, yet she had to be pushed to publish. She did not see it as self-expression anymore, only as a means of building her “brand”. The creativity that once flowed from curiosity became strangled by a need to appear flawless.
2. The High Achiever and the Weight of Comparison
Perfectionism rarely exists in isolation. It often grows in the shadow of high-achieving families and inherited expectations. Her brother & sister-in-law are doctors, wealthy due to the hard work to get where they are. Her parents were intelligent, hard-working, and materially successful. Even her nieces and nephews were high performers.
She compared her life to theirs constantly. Despite being financially secure and loved, she saw herself as having failed, not because of lack of achievement, but because it was not the right kind of success. Coaching culture fed this dissatisfaction. It told her she “deserved more” and that “manifestation” would deliver it. When it did not, the pressure to live up to her self-image as a high achiever only intensified.
3. From Self-Blame to Scapegoating: The Coaching Shift
Garber notes that:
“This perfectionist tends to fluctuate between blaming the system and blaming themselves (but mostly blaming themselves, which is self-protective), without ever developing a deeper understanding of the relevant forces.”
Before coaching, she blamed herself for not being where she wanted to be. After coaching, she found someone else to blame, me. Her unhappiness, her weight, her lack of satisfaction, all became reflections of my supposed shortcomings.
If she could not manifest what she wanted, it was because my energy was “blocking” her. If she did not feel fulfilled, it was because I did not share her interests. The irony was that coaching gave her a psychological vocabulary that justified resentment, but not reflection. It turned legitimate frustration into a weapon, reframed as “boundaries” and “alignment”.
4. The Myth of Unmet Needs
One day I was told, “My needs aren’t being met.” When I asked what they were, she could not articulate them, because they were not tangible. They were bound up in spiritual goals and manifesting desires that coaching had convinced her were sacred.
Garber asks,
“Am I being exploited? Can I perpetually continue to suppress the sense that my needs aren’t even considered?”
In her case, “needs” became a moving target. If she wanted to bushwalk and did not, it was my fault. If she wanted to write and did not, it was because I was not inspiring enough. She could have joined a walking group or written freely as she once did, but instead she projected her paralysis outward. It was safer to see me as the obstacle than to face the contradiction between her ideals and her reality.
5. The Echo Chamber of Like Minds
Garber suggests that socially prescribed perfectionists “overvalue social security” and seek approval from others. In practice, this meant surrounding herself with like-minded people, spiritualists, coaches, believers in the same pseudoscientific frameworks.
Her genuine friendships dwindled over time. Gravitating towards like minded people, manifesting, coaching, self help types. When she finally found a colleague at UTS who shared her love for “woo woo”, it was like finding ideological oxygen. Dissenting voices were out, validation was in. That validation was not friendship. It was collusion, an agreement to maintain each other’s delusions under the guise of “growth”.
6. Validation Through Coaching: The Illusion of Progress
Garber concludes:
“Socially prescribed perfectionists often enter treatment feeling deeply depressed and anxious, yet downplay both states to themselves and their therapists. In time, we all discover how unsustainable one’s plan for being really is.”
This perfectly describes the endgame. Coaching promised her liberation from perfectionism but only deepened it. The endless self-improvement, the retreats-Tony Robbins, the “breakthroughs”, all kept her trapped in the same pattern of striving, never satisfied, never enough.
Each new “transformation” reset the goalposts. When she could not maintain the high, she blamed the environment, the relationship, or anyone who did not share the vision. It was not growth. It was avoidance, a spiritualised form of self-rejection masquerading as empowerment.
The Lesson: When Growth Becomes Self-Erasure
Garber’s framework helps explain what coaching culture often conceals, that perfectionism and people-pleasing do not vanish through mindset shifts or manifesting mantras. They mutate. They find new justifications, new systems, and new gurus to serve.
When someone learns to reframe self-blame as enlightenment, they do not heal. They dissolve accountability into ideology. The system, whether it is family expectations, corporate culture, or the coaching industry, remains intact. Only the story changes.
True healing does not come from rewriting your life into a narrative of perpetual growth. It comes from accepting imperfection, facing limits, and acknowledging the systems that profit from your self-doubt.
Until then, transformation will always have a body count.
